Record $33 million FELA verdict · SMART-TD Designated Legal Counsel · No win, no fee · Representing railroaders nationwideCall (888) 425-1212
Do I Have a Case?

Free case report in about two minutes

ResultsAttorneysArticlesCall (888) 425-1212
railroad injury

FELA Law Firm

Is Your Railroad Injury a FELA Case? What Proves Fault

Executive Summary~2 min listen~7 min read
In this article
  • Which missing safety precaution turns an injury into a case
  • Clearance, alarm and event recorder proof behind verdicts
  • Vibration and ballast injuries and their deadline trap
  • Four early mistakes and the records to preserve first
0:000:00
The Bottom Line

A railroad injury, sudden or built up over years, can be a FELA case if railroad negligence played any part in causing it. Event recorder data may be kept only one year, and the filing deadline is generally three years, so waiting can cost you the proof and the claim.

three yearsFELA's deadline from accrual, which can start before a cumulative injury is diagnosed.
one yearHow long federal rules generally require event recorder data kept after an accident.
180 daysSeparate FRSA deadline to file a complaint over retaliation for reporting an injury.
What You Need to Know

Injuries from ballast walking, vibration or repetitive work are FELA claims, but the deadline can start before a doctor names the problem. In Fries, the Seventh Circuit held a claim expired in 1984, a year before the May 1985 diagnosis, because symptoms worsened at work. Assumption of risk is abolished, and a safety statute violation bars any reduction for the worker's partial fault.

What To Do Next
1.Report the injury and get medical care, then note witnesses, equipment numbers and radio channel.
2.Demand preservation of event recorder data and radio logs; retention may be only one year.
3.Talk with a FELA lawyer before giving a recorded statement or signing any railroad forms.
4.Write down when gradual symptoms began at work; the three-year clock can start before diagnosis.
5.File any FRSA retaliation complaint within 180 days of the injury report that triggered it.
Share

Get insights like this in your inbox

A railroad injury may support a claim under the Federal Employers' Liability Act (FELA) when the railroad's negligence played any part, even the slightest, in causing it. The Supreme Court approved that standard in CSX Transportation, Inc. v. McBride, and it covers sudden and gradual harm alike. FELA is not strict liability. The worker must prove a failed safety duty that contributed to the injury. When the railroad violates a safety statute such as the Safety Appliance Act or the Locomotive Inspection Act, the violation is negligence per se, so the worker need not separately prove carelessness, though causation must still be shown. This article sorts railroad injury claims by how the injury happened and what proves the failure.

Whether a Railroad Injury Is a Case Turns on the Safety Duty the Railroad Failed

A railroad injury is a potential FELA claim when the railroad's act or omission made the work more dangerous than it had to be. The question is not whether railroading is dangerous. The question is which reasonable precaution was missing. Section 51 imposes liability for injury resulting "in whole or in part" from railroad negligence. It covers conductors, engineers, switchmen, maintenance of way workers and carmen employed by covered railroads such as BNSF and Union Pacific. Contractors need individual review.

"It was just part of the job" is not a defense, because Section 54 abolishes assumption of risk. Under Section 53, partial fault reduces damages in proportion rather than ending the claim. The same section bars any reduction when the railroad's violation of a safety statute contributed to the injury.

The claim can proceed in state or federal court under Section 56. Railroad workers fall under FELA, the Federal Employers Liability Act, rather than workers' comp, a difference the firm's Railroad Claims page explains. Proof of a specific failure is what decides whether a railroad injury is a case.

Sudden Railroad Injuries and the Evidence That Proved the Railroad Failed

$4.2M Pin-Lifter Verdict Upheld on the Railroad's Own Video: Four Sudden Injuries Mapped to Proof
$4.2M Pin-Lifter Verdict Upheld on the Railroad's Own Video, With Four Sudden Injuries Mapped to the Proof That Won Them. Source: U.S. Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit, 1995, DeBiasio v. Illinois Central Railroad, 52 F.3d 678

Crushed in the Yard, Run Over on Track, Struck by an Unexpected Movement

Crushed between railcars ($10 million verdict). That Chicago verdict involved a railroad worker crushed between two railcars. In a separate case, Parsons v. Norfolk Southern Railway Company, track work narrowed the space between adjacent yard tracks to as little as 10 feet 6 inches, leaving no safe clearance for a worker riding the side of a car. When yard tracks run too close together, clearance surveys, track plans and dated photographs prove the failure. They must be secured before the track is realigned.

Run over by a ballast regulator. When a machine's backup alarm fails, alarm inspections, repair history and defect reports show whether the railroad knew the alarm was out, and for how long.

Struck by an unauthorized train movement. Event recorder data, radio recordings, dispatch records and the movement authority show who moved the train and on whose word. A radio communication rule the railroad did not follow can also supply the failure. Federal radio standards appear in 49 C.F.R. Part 220, one of several FRA regulations that can supply the safety duty, though each case's governing rule comes from its own record.

Railroad Injuries That Build Over Years Are FELA Claims Too

Injuries that build over years from ballast walking, locomotive vibration or repetitive work are FELA claims too, as Urie v. Thompson recognized. The claim still requires proof of a preventable condition, not wear alone.

A Cumulative Injury Claim Expired in 1984, a Year Before the 1985 Diagnosis
A Cumulative Injury Claim Expired in 1984, a Year Before the 1985 Diagnosis. Source: Seventh Circuit, 1990, Fries v. Chicago & Northwestern Transportation Co., 909 F.2d 1092

One example is a spine worn down by locomotive vibration. Assignment and equipment history, ride quality and maintenance records, prior complaints and a medical timeline carry these cases.

Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. Every case depends on its own facts.

Section 56 allows three years from accrual. Urie refused to penalize a worker's blameless ignorance. Courts now generally start a cumulative injury's clock when the worker knew or should have known of the injury and its work cause. In Fries v. Chicago & Northwestern Transportation Co., the Seventh Circuit held that a claim expired in 1984, a year before the May 1985 diagnosis. The court relied in part on symptoms that had worsened at work and eased away from it. The railroad will point to early aches the same way, and how courts weigh them depends on the facts and the circuit. Waiting for the condition to get bad enough can cost the claim.

The first priority is to go to a doctor and inform the treaters of the nature of the job tasks, including any unsafe conditions that could have contributed to the injuries, such as bad ballast or hard-to-throw switches.

What Usually Goes Wrong and What to Preserve First

Railroad injury claims usually go wrong early:

  • Treating the injury as part of the job.
  • Giving a recorded statement or signing forms early.
  • Waiting while records are overwritten, repaired away or discarded.
  • Underreporting symptoms to stay on the board.

Good faith injury reporting is protected under the Federal Railroad Safety Act (FRSA), which sets a separate complaint deadline of 180 days. After a report, supervisors say things like, "Do you really want to report this?" with the implication that the job will get harder, or they ask whether the worker wants to go home and see if it goes away overnight.

The claim agent usually wants a written or recorded statement. Claim agents are trained to get statements that help the railroad. For example, they will not ask follow-up questions or try to get details of how the negligent condition or equipment caused the injury, and the injured railroader is not prepared to supply the details needed to protect their rights, especially if they are treating or in pain.

The steps after an injury, in order:

  1. Report the injury and get medical care.
  2. Write down witnesses, time, location, equipment numbers and the radio channel.
  3. Have a preservation demand sent for event recorder downloads, radio recordings, alarm and maintenance logs, clearance surveys, and injury records the railroad keeps for the Federal Railroad Administration under Part 225.
  4. Talk with a FELA lawyer before signing anything.

Federal rules generally require keeping event recorder data only one year after a reportable accident.

Many times railroad workers do not have a copy of the written statement or injury report they provided to management, and that is a big mistake. Also, while there are rules about taking photos, it is important, if possible, to take photos of the unsafe condition as it appeared on the date of injury.

A minor injury that heals with no lost time may never need a claim. Lost time, surgery or a permanent restriction warrants a lawyer's review, and those same facts shape what a railroad injury case is worth.

In every situation above, the claim turns on proof of a specific safety duty the railroad failed. Even under FELA's relaxed standard, the worker must still prove that failure played a part in causing the injury, so the records that show it are what to protect first.

This article is provided for general information and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney client relationship. Legal outcomes depend on the facts of each case, and past results do not guarantee a similar outcome. If you were injured working on the railroad, discuss your situation with qualified counsel.

Hoey, Farina & McMahon, P.C.

A Chicago trial firm representing injured railroad workers, passengers and their families nationwide. Questions about your own case? Meet William McMahon or ask for a free case evaluation.

Practice area

FELA Railroad Injury

Injured working for a railroad. See how we handle these cases

This article is general information, not legal advice for your situation.

Free Case Evaluation · No Win, No Fee

The railroad has its lawyers. Get yours.

Tell us what happened. We will give you straight answers about your rights, your deadlines, and what your claim may be worth. Free and confidential.